DADT and the GOP's Faux Populism

Back in the spring, when Democrats -- after a decades-long odyssey -- were preparing to pass a comprehensive health insurance bill, Republicans expressed outrage their opponents would do something the public didn't want them to do: the polls, they said, showed a clear majority of Americans opposed the bill. A CNN poll in March showed that 59 percent of respondents didn't like it. Passing the bill in the face of such opposition, the GOP said, was profoundly undemocratic.

Fast-forward to yesterday, when the GOP blocked progress of a bill that would repeal "Don't Ask Don't Tell," the law that lets the armed forces boot gay members. What's funny about this? Well, polls show that around 57-58 percent of Americans favor the DADT repeal -- almost exactly the same percentage that opposed the health care bill. The same Republican Party members who stood for the perogatives of majority-according-to-polling ignored the polling when it conflicted with their stances.

Why? Easy enough to guess. Some Republican senators presumably do believe -- without merit, I think -- that letting gays serve openly will disrupt the armed forces. Others were pandering to their anti-gay base, or just signing on for party unity. Whatever. I'm sure there are some other principled reasons for opposing the bill, but the fact is this: the GOP is staunchly for what the majority of Americans want, unless it isn't.

Comments

KhabaLox said…
Please cross-post this to Freedom Pub. :)

Also, the Google Ad I got was for a Gay Key West resort.
Ben Boychuk said…
There should be -- if you'll forgive the pun -- a straight up or down vote on DADT and the DREAM Act. The problem with attaching these controversial bills to a larger defense spending package is the sort of partisan point-scoring gotcha crap we saw yesterday. (Note, too, the Democrats who voted against cloture.)

We've talked and columnized about this before (in February, I think). I generally favor getting rid of the law, if the armed services can figure out how to make it work without undermining the essential mission of the military.

Popular posts from this blog

Why John Brascia is the secret hero of Bing Crosby's "White Christmas."

So I hate my fucking colostomy

Mr. Mom Chronicles: Working At Home