Friday, June 6, 2008

Commie bastards

One of Andrew Sullivan's readers makes a point that I was trying to make shortly before the end of redblueamerica:
As a specialist on Soviet history and more particularly on the Soviet Gulag, I am just so annoyed by the ignorance of statements like this:

"I have said publicly, and I will again, that unless he proves me wrong, he is a Marxist," - Tom DeLay.

"And did the Obama rally begin with the Soviet National Anthem?" - Hugh Hewitt

Put these guys and their ilk in my class for a semester and let them understand what Marxism and Communism were really about. Progressive taxation, no matter how much one might be opposed to it, is simply qualitatively different than the elimination of private ownership of the means of production. Government regulation, even if it interferes with the economy, is not the equivalent of total nationalization of the economy. These are not minor distinctions, but fundamental to the very definition of what Soviet Communism was, and why it had the outcomes it did. The attempt to tie Democrats and liberals (the latter of which was a term of abuse within the Soviet political structure) is incredibly ignorant of the actual history and structure of Soviet Communism.

Maybe I'm wrong, but it does seem to me that there has been a late revival of red-baiting. But it's been nearly 20 years (!) since the Cold War ended, and memories are short. People who attempt to paint Obama as a secret Soviet are either lying, or they've forgotten what real Marxism looked like.

2 comments:

Ben said...

I can't defend DeLay, but I'm going to at least try to explain the Hewitt quote since I remember listening to the show that day. It's actually trivial stuff. He was talking about the Decemberists performing at the big Obama rally in Oregon last month. I think you blogged about that little tempest in a teapot, didn't you Joel? Anyway, some callers made mention of how the band sometimes (always? I don't know) opens their live shows with the Soviet anthem. Hewitt's point wasn't that Obama is a secret commie but that he's a radical and a tin-eared dope for letting his campaign book a band that opens with the Soviet anthem. Just another little gotcha game in the long campaign.

Anonymous said...

Obama is apparently so tin-eared that he only today took down the "Marxists/Socialists/Communists for Obama" link on his campaign page.

Powerline linked to it yesterday. Now it's gone.

Jim